Cohesive Design by Committee

Most of today’s product design shortcomings can be linked to disparate objectives caused by a lack of communication among the teams that mold a product.

Each group in the product circle has its own set of priorities, and therein lies the problem. Marketing wants to increase leads and brand perception. Product managers seek to be on time and in budget. Manufacturers focus on avoiding defects, and so on. This is supposed to create a great product. According to Peter Merholz, founding partner and president of Adaptive Path, this actually causes one or more of these sticky situations:

1. Design by committee: “In an effort to achieve consensus, innovative impulses are dampened.”

2. Design by accretion: “Products are cobbled together in a serial fashion, each department contributing without regard to what the other groups are doing.”

3. Design by gauntlet: “Projects are subject to so many approval processes that they are often stalled before shipping.”

A better product management option is a system in which product managers, marketers, designers, engineers, and user advocates work closely on a single project.  Ideally, products should be passed back and forth between groups in order to create a cohesive, well-designed product or service.


Vickilynn is a Novelist whose first book "Waving Backwards" was published in July 2015. She is also a Blogger at Adoptionfind Blog. Previously, she was a Freelance marketing copywriter at OpenView.
You might also like ...
Product-Led Growth
How to Grow Faster With (Near) $0 CAC
With climbing inflation, waves of tech layoffs, and tighter focus on profitability, “grow at any cost” is no longer viable,...
by Kyle Poyar
Product-Led Growth
How Supermetrics Grew To €50M And Beyond
I first met the founders of Supermetrics—the hottest PLG company that you probably haven’t heard of—in the most unusual of...
by Kyle Poyar
Product-Led Growth
Staying Scrappy: How To Build And Scale High-Impact Growth Teams
How did I end up in PLG SaaS? Looking back at the start of my career, technology and data became...
by Lauren Schuman